Formulated Consensus: 29 Shortstops in the Hitter Top 100
FORMULATED CONSENSUS: WEEKLY INSIGHTS
Eight formulated prospect lists averaged into one board, as of 11/17/2026
Nearly three of every ten hitters in the Formulated Consensus top 100 are shortstops: 29 of them, from Eli Willits at No. 1 to Sammy Stafura at No. 100. The Formulated Consensus is the average of eight formulated prospect lists, with OOPSY Peak counting like any other list. A prospect needs four of the eight lists to get an average rank, and hitters and pitchers have separate boards. Tight, Moderate and Split describe how spread out a player’s ranks are compared with the players ranked near him: Tight is unusually close, Split unusually far apart, Moderate in between. This is a cut of the board as of 11/17/2026. Willits and Aidan Miller (No. 5) are on the cooldown list below, so this week’s closer looks start with Rangers shortstop Sebastian Walcott at No. 7, with an average rank of 38.7 across all eight lists. The bigger story is where OOPSY Peak breaks from the group. It has Stafura at No. 522, 422 spots below his Consensus rank, Elian Pena at No. 312 (Consensus No. 76) and John Gil at No. 189 (Consensus No. 54). On the other side, only three shortstops get a better rank from OOPSY Peak than from the group, led by Jesus Baez at No. 47, 35 spots above his Consensus No. 82.
What Moved Since Last Week
Since the 11/11 board, eight hitters changed agreement labels, and OOPSY Peak moved seven of them down. Josiah Ragsdale took the biggest hit: he went from Tight to Moderate and dropped from Consensus No. 41 to No. 59 as OOPSY Peak fell from No. 145 to No. 395. Three hitters moved into Tight: Emmanuel Rodriguez (average rank 86.4 to 91.0, OOPSY Peak No. 9 to No. 32), Kaelen Culpepper (average rank 125.1 to 130.7, OOPSY Peak No. 50 to No. 93) and Yairo Padilla, one of this week’s shortstops, who climbed from Consensus No. 96 to No. 89 even as OOPSY Peak moved him from No. 76 to No. 98. Jaison Chourio also went from Tight to Moderate (Consensus No. 76 to No. 81, OOPSY Peak No. 168 to No. 306). Three went from Split to Moderate: Rainiel Rodriguez, Dax Kilby (Consensus No. 57 to No. 61, OOPSY Peak No. 70 to No. 106) and Josue Briceno (Consensus No. 99 to No. 92, OOPSY Peak No. 25 to No. 37).
The Shortstops in the Hitter Top 100
Every shortstop in the hitter top 100, ordered by Consensus rank:
| Cons. # | Player | Pos | Team | Age | Lvl | Avg Rank | Coverage | Agreement | OOPSY Peak |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eli Willits | SS | WSN | 18 | AA | 12.0 | 8/8 | Tight | 3 |
| 5 | Aidan Miller | SS | PHI | 22 | AAA | 26.3 | 4/8 | Tight | 44 |
| 7 | Sebastian Walcott | SS | TEX | 20 | AAA | 38.7 | 8/8 | Tight | 16 |
| 10 | Tate Southisene | SS | ATL | 19 | AA | 46.9 | 7/8 | Tight | 64 |
| 14 | Franklin Arias | SS | BOS | 20 | AAA | 59.5 | 8/8 | Moderate | 15 |
| 16 | Jesus Made | SS | MIL | 19 | AA | 60.9 | 8/8 | Moderate | 17 |
| 17 | Leo De Vries | SS | ATH | 19 | AA | 61.8 | 8/8 | Moderate | 13 |
| 18 | Brady Ebel | SS | MIL | 18 | A+ | 64.4 | 7/8 | Tight | 51 |
| 21 | Josuar Gonzalez | SS | SFG | 18 | A | 77.4 | 7/8 | Moderate | 94 |
| 26 | Sebastian Dos Santos | SS | STL | 18 | A | 82.4 | 7/8 | Tight | 31 |
| 29 | Josh Adamczewski | SS | MIL | 21 | AA | 84.8 | 8/8 | Moderate | 77 |
| 35 | Jaiden Lo Re | SS | BAL | 19 | A+ | 102.3 | 7/8 | Moderate | 90 |
| 36 | JoJo Parker | SS | TOR | 19 | A+ | 102.7 | 7/8 | Tight | 113 |
| 38 | Miguel Hernandez | SS | STL | 18 | A | 104.0 | 7/8 | Moderate | 53 |
| 41 | Welbyn Francisca | SS | CLE | 20 | AA | 108.8 | 8/8 | Tight | 120 |
| 44 | Jhonny Level | SS | SFG | 19 | A+ | 117.1 | 8/8 | Split | 63 |
| 45 | Yolfran Castillo | SS | TEX | 19 | A+ | 118.2 | 8/8 | Moderate | 272 |
| 51 | Luis Pena | SS | MIL | 19 | AA | 126.3 | 8/8 | Moderate | 58 |
| 53 | Kaelen Culpepper | SS | MIN | 23 | MLB | 130.7 | 7/8 | Tight | 93 |
| 54 | John Gil | SS | ATL | 20 | AA | 131.8 | 8/8 | Moderate | 189 |
| 55 | Arjun Nimmala | SS | LAA | 20 | AA | 133.6 | 8/8 | Moderate | 68 |
| 61 | Dax Kilby | SS | NYY | 19 | A | 143.6 | 7/8 | Moderate | 106 |
| 64 | Bryan Rincon | SS | PHI | 22 | AA | 146.5 | 8/8 | Moderate | 110 |
| 67 | Wyatt Sanford | SS | PIT | 20 | A+ | 151.2 | 8/8 | Moderate | 177 |
| 75 | Emil Morales | SS | LAD | 19 | A+ | 168.5 | 8/8 | Split | 69 |
| 76 | Elian Pena | SS | NYM | 18 | A+ | 168.8 | 8/8 | Moderate | 312 |
| 82 | Jesus Baez | SS | STL | 21 | AA | 180.2 | 8/8 | Split | 47 |
| 89 | Yairo Padilla | SS | STL | 19 | A+ | 199.9 | 7/8 | Tight | 98 |
| 100 | Sammy Stafura | SS | NYM | 21 | A+ | 220.8 | 8/8 | Moderate | 522 |
Rangers shortstop Sebastian Walcott sits at Consensus No. 7 among hitters, and four lists have him inside their top seven: BaGS is the highest list shown on him, at No. 1, followed by PLFR at No. 3, PARS at No. 4 and LFX at No. 7. OOPSY Peak is cooler at No. 16, nine spots below the Consensus.
Braves shortstop Tate Southisene carries a Tight label at Consensus No. 10 among hitters, but that label does not mean OOPSY Peak agrees with the others. PLFR has him No. 4 and PG+ has him No. 15, while OOPSY Peak has him No. 64, a 54-spot gap that works out to 84%. P.Tilt is the lowest list shown on him, at No. 93.
Red Sox shortstop Franklin Arias, Consensus No. 14 among hitters, is one of only two shortstops in the table where OOPSY Peak lands within a spot of the Consensus: it has him No. 15. The other lists are less settled, and his label is Moderate. PG+ and PARS both have him No. 1 and LFX has him No. 4, yet his average rank is 59.5, so at least one list sits far lower.
Brewers shortstop Jesus Made, Consensus No. 16 among hitters, is the other one: OOPSY Peak has him No. 17. LFX ranks him No. 1, FScore No. 7 and PARS No. 8, but his average rank sits at 60.9 and his label is Moderate. He is one of four Brewers shortstops in the table, along with Brady Ebel, Josh Adamczewski and Luis Pena. Only the Cardinals match that, with four of their own.
Athletics shortstop Leo De Vries, Consensus No. 17 among hitters, is the only featured name OOPSY Peak ranks above the group, at No. 13, four spots higher. The other two shortstops OOPSY Peak ranks above the group are Jesus Baez and Emil Morales. LFX has De Vries No. 3 and BaGS No. 4, and his label is Moderate.
Still on the Board
Three shortstops from recent editions are on cooldown but still hold their ground: Eli Willits (Consensus No. 1, OOPSY No. 3), Aidan Miller (Consensus No. 5, OOPSY No. 44) and Sebastian Dos Santos (Consensus No. 26, OOPSY No. 31). Miller’s 39-spot gap is the one to keep an eye on. For dynasty managers, the shortstops where OOPSY Peak breaks hardest from the group, Stafura, Elian Pena and Gil on the low side and Jesus Baez on the high side, are the ones worth a second look before you trade for or away from them.
Keep Digging
The full board, with every list’s rank, the agreement labels and a low-coverage view, is on the Formulated Consensus page. STS members also get the full OOPSY Peak rankings and player cards. Become a member. See you next week.