Skip to content

Prospect of the Day: OOPSY Has Brennan Hudson 733 Spots Higher Than the Formulated Consensus

November 17, 2026 · Prospect of the Day · Ross Jensen
Prospect of the Day: OOPSY Has Brennan Hudson 733 Spots Higher Than the Formulated Consensus
Brennan Hudson headshot

PROSPECT OF THE DAY: BRENNAN HUDSON

DH, CHC | as of 11/17/2026

22Season Age
No. 350STS fantasy ranking
1.6Peak WAR
-130-day move

Brennan Hudson struck out in nearly a third of his 68 plate appearances in 2026, and OOPSY still has him No. 350 overall and No. 98 among prospects. The other formulated lists are nowhere close. The Formulated Consensus has the Cubs’ designated hitter No. 822 among hitters, 733 spots below OOPSY’s No. 89 among hitter prospects. OOPSY’s case rests on his power, and the strikeouts are what stand between him and a bigger jump.

The Consensus Is Cooler, by 733 Spots

Only five of the eight lists in the Formulated Consensus rank him at all: OOPSY plus four of the seven partner lists. Blended, they put him No. 822 among hitters, 733 spots (89%) below OOPSY’s No. 89 among hitter prospects. The four partner lists run from No. 961 to No. 1796 among hitters, so none of them has him anywhere near its top 100. Even the high mark, Prospect Larceny’s formulated ranking (PLFR) at No. 961 among hitters, sits 872 spots below OOPSY. On Hudson, OOPSY is out on its own.

Power That Plays

OOPSY Peak projects Hudson for 24 homers at his peak, 17th of 89 hitters in the top 100, inside a .220/.328/.400 line. His best STS grade is a plus 60 power mark, and that kind of pop plays in any fantasy format. It’s why OOPSY keeps him in the top 100 even though his 1.6 Peak WAR sits outside the top 50 marks on the board. Among the six designated hitters in the top 100, he ranks sixth in the STS fantasy ranking and fifth in Peak WAR, a hair ahead of Andrew Williamson. You are not coming to Hudson for speed: OOPSY Peak projects three steals.

A Rough 2026 Season

Hudson’s 2026 was a 68-plate-appearance sample, and it was rough: .200/.353/.364 with two homers and no steals, a 32.4% strikeout rate and a 17.6% walk rate. The walks kept his on-base percentage afloat while the strikeouts dragged down the rest. The Pulse, which grades this season only, put him 1260th of 2,140 prospects with a 77.2 wRC+, where 100 is average. OOPSY Peak, which projects his peak, has him No. 89 among hitter prospects. It also weighs his track record before 2026, so one short, rough season moves it less than it moves The Pulse.

Miguel Hernandez Holds the Next Spot

The next real step is the top 50 overall, and Cardinals shortstop Miguel Hernandez holds that line at No. 50, a full 50 spots ahead. Hernandez projects for 3.3 Peak WAR to Hudson’s 1.6, a gap of 1.7. Peak WAR and the STS fantasy ranking are different calculations off the same OOPSY Peak numbers, so the ranks may vary, but a gap that size means Hudson’s projection would need to grow, not just hold. If he closes it, a lower strikeout rate is the likeliest way.

Strikeouts Are the Number to Watch

OOPSY projects a 29% strikeout rate for Hudson, well above the 21% median for hitters in the OOPSY Peak top 100, and that comes with an average 50 hit grade. It is a little lower than the 32.4% he posted in 2026, but it is still the biggest hole in his profile. If he trims the strikeouts further, that’s the piece most likely to move his OOPSY projection.

What It Means for Your Roster

A 733-spot disagreement is a big one, but ranking gaps alone are not a trade signal. If Hudson is on your roster, there is no need to move him; keep an eye on the strikeout rate. If you are shopping for power, let the price in your league guide you. At 22, he has plenty of time to continue developing.

Keep Digging

Every prospect’s STS fantasy ranking, Peak WAR and grades live on the OOPSY Peak page. STS members get the full rankings and player cards. Become a member. Another prospect tomorrow.

Data: OOPSY Peak as of 11/16/2026; Formulated Consensus as of 11/16/2026; The Pulse (2026 season).

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *